ComplianceEmployment Litigation and Legal Action

When Someone Else’s Bias Becomes the Employer’s Problem

retaliation claims in the workplace

A decisionmaker’s ignorance of an employee’s complaint does not shield the employer from a retaliation claim if someone else in the chain (like a supervisor, an investigator, or a recommender) knew about the protected activity and acted with retaliatory intent. That bias travels with the information, all the way to the final decision.

If you are an employee who was terminated by someone who claims they had no idea you ever made a complaint, or an employer who routed a termination through a senior executive precisely to create the appearance of a clean decision, this post is for you. The cat’s paw theory of liability is one of the most misunderstood and underestimated concepts in California employment retaliation law. At Sherman Law Corporation, our employment litigation practice handles exactly these cases.

A common defense to a retaliation claim is that the person who made the final call, an HR director, a senior executive, or an outside decisionmaker, had never even heard of the employee’s complaint and could not have retaliated for something they did not know about. That defense sounds airtight. It often is not.

What the Cat’s Paw Theory Says

California courts recognize what is sometimes called the cat’s paw theory of liability. A decisionmaker’s own ignorance of an employee’s protected activity does not shield the employer if someone else involved in the process, the supervisor who wrote the report, recommended the termination, or fed information up the chain, knew about the protected activity and acted with a retaliatory motive, so long as that person’s bias was a substantial factor in the ultimate decision. The unbiased decisionmaker becomes, in effect, an unwitting instrument of someone else’s retaliation. Reeves v. Safeway Stores, Inc., 121 Cal.App.4th 95 (2004).

How Bias Travels Through the ChainĀ 

This matters because it is common practice for companies to route a termination through someone several steps removed from the employee’s actual complaint, in part to create exactly the appearance of a clean, unbiased decision. If the information the final decision-maker relied on, a performance write-up, an investigation summary, or a recommendation to terminate was generated or shaped by someone with a retaliatory motive, the taint travels with it. Often times, this is proven by messages between the decisionmaker and the person who directs the adverse action.

For employees, this means a case is not over just because the person who signed the termination paperwork says they did not know about your complaint. For employers, it means the safest move is never routing an adverse decision through a chain that includes someone who was the subject of, or a witness to, the employee’s protected complaint, without first understanding how much that person’s input shaped the final call.

Takeaway for Employees and Employers

Employees who were retaliated against should look past the name on the termination letter. Ask who actually generated the write-ups, the investigation findings, or the recommendation the final decisionmaker relied on, and whether that person knew about your complaint. Obtain all electronic communications that refer or relate to the termination. That chain can be where the case is won.

Employers should not assume a decision is protected just because it was made or approved by someone with no knowledge of the complaint. Before finalizing any adverse action, trace where the information behind it came from, and consult counsel if anyone in that chain was a subject of, or witness to, the employee’s protected activity.

For additional information or if you wish to seek employment counsel, please contact Lisa Sherman for a free consultation at (323)488-2087 or at Lisa@sherm-law.com.

Frequently Asked Questions About Retaliation in the Workplace

1. What is the cat’s paw theory of retaliation in California?

The cat’s paw theory holds that an employer can be liable for retaliation even if the final decisionmaker had no knowledge of your protected activity, as long as someone earlier in the process (like a supervisor, investigator, or recommender) did know and acted with retaliatory intent, and that person’s bias was a substantial factor in the outcome. The unbiased decisionmaker becomes an unwitting instrument of someone else’s retaliation.

2. My termination was approved by a senior executive who had no idea I had filed a complaint. Do I still have a case?

Possibly yes. What matters is not just who signed the termination paperwork, but who generated the information that led to that decision. If a supervisor or HR representative who knew about your complaint wrote the performance write-ups, shaped the investigation findings, or recommended your termination, their bias may have tainted the entire process. Contact our employee representation team to assess your specific situation.

3. What evidence do I need to prove a cat’s paw retaliation claim?

You need to show that someone in the decision-making chain knew about your protected activity, that they acted with retaliatory intent, and that their input was a substantial factor in the final adverse action. Electronic communications (including emails, texts, and internal messages) between the recommender and the decision-maker are often where this evidence lives. The paper trail matters enormously. See our post on why documentation shapes these cases.

4. As an employer, how do I protect myself from cat’s paw liability?

Before finalizing any adverse action, trace where the information behind it actually came from. If anyone in the chain, like the supervisor who wrote the write-up, the investigator who compiled the report, or the manager who made the recommendation, was a subject of or witness to the employee’s protected complaint, you need to understand how much their input shaped the final call before proceeding. Consult counsel before acting, not after.

5. Can routing a termination through HR or a senior executive protect us from retaliation claims?

Not by itself. Routing a decision through someone with no knowledge of a complaint can be part of a defensible process, but only if that person genuinely made an independent decision based on untainted information. If the write-ups, investigation summaries, or recommendations they relied on were generated by someone with a retaliatory motive, the taint travels with the information regardless of who signs off at the end.

6. How can Sherman Law Corporation help with a retaliation claim in California?

Whether you are an employee building a retaliation case or an employer trying to structure a lawful adverse action process, Sherman Law Corporation works directly with you from the first conversation through resolution. Lisa Sherman has over 26 years of experience on both sides of these cases. Contact our office at (323) 488-2087 or at Lisa@sherm-law.com for a free consultation.